Mystery Reviews, April 1, 2012

Author Cara Black (Murder at the Lanterne Rouge) was the featured speaker at my local library recently, and during the course of the program she mused about how mysteries today can engage a wide spectrum of readers because of all the other elements involved in the story. Without using the term, Black was talking about genre crossing. She held her audience of mystery and nonmystery readers spellbound with anecdotes about researching the events and people of Paris so that her heroine Aimée Leduc could have yet another adventure. What became clear was that folks are looking for a good story, and they’re not particularly worried about how a book is labeled or shelved.

First-person narratives also resonate strongly with readers. Their directness has the effect of news coming across the kitchen table. Listen to attorney Jack MacTaggart, who just happens to inherit a dead horse case from his boss in Chuck Greaves’s amusing Hush Money. Criminologist Cait Morgan makes you believe you are there with her as she experiences the beauty of Nice, France, described so well by Cathy Ace in The Corpse with the Silver Tongue.

In a similar manner, the oft-used and very popular journalist-as-protagonist mystery subgenre can appeal to any curious reader because so much information about a given topic is imparted along with the story line. In Wildcat Play , Helen Knode’s feisty and tough onetime film critic Ann Whitehead is now working on oil rigs in a remote corner of California’s San Joaquin valley. And Wayne Arthurson’s gambling addict Edmonton reporter, Leo Desroches, returns in A Killing Winter, wrestling with personal demons while pursuing his newspaper stories.

Which leads me to the allure of the flawed hero, key in the two aforementioned titles. Add to this group Joseph Olshan’s conflicted heroine Catherine Winslow, whose prickly nature works to ratchet up the tension in Cloudland.

We like it in movies and TV shows, and also as a subgenre, based on the growing appeal of what I call police consultant/procedural stories. One unique entry your readers might like is Richard Helms’s The Unresolved Seventh, a moody piece whose psychologist happens to suffer from Asperger’s syndrome. Orfrom a completely different stance, try Keith McCarthy’s father-sonpolice surgeon story (Nor All Your Tears), which somehow makes a serial killer crime light.

The Series Lineup this month salutes two series celebrating their 20th entries. Rita Mae Brown and Sneaky Pie Brown keep purring along with Mrs. Murphy in The Big Cat Nap , while Katherine Hall Page’s Faith Fairchild series takes a look back in The Body in the Boudoir. Anne Perry ushers in a new year and her 25th Charlotte and Thomas Pitt title, Dorchester Terrace. Readers find great comfort with these familiar characters, whose story lines they know as if the characters were family members. If you haven’t sampled one of these time-honored series yet, perhaps this will be the year.


Dorothy Gilman, creator of the fictional garden club member‚ turned‚ CIA spy, Mrs. Pollifax, died February 2. Gilman’s protagonist, she of many hats and exotic travels, made her debut in The Unexpected Mrs. Pollifax in 1966 and enjoyed a long and successful series. Many readers cite Gilman’s stand-alones, such as The Tightrope Walker , as their favorites; her romantic suspense was along the lines of Mary Stewart. Searching several library catalogs, I was tickled by the abundance of Gilman titles currently available in all manner of format: ebook, large print, paper back, hardcover, and audiobook on CD. The Mystery Writers of America named Gilman a Grand Master in 2010.

starred review starGreaves, Chuck. Hush Money. Minotaur: St. Martin’s. May 2012. c.328p. ISBN 9781250005236. $24.99. M

When Sydney Everett’s Olympic-caliber jumping horse, Hush Puppy, dies suddenly, her law firm jumps into action, sending out young Pasadena, CA, attorney Jack MacTaggart. Sydney is worth watching because another horse she owned died under suspicious circumstances just a few years earlier. Jack follows a circuitous paper trail and learns that Sydney was guilty of insurance fraud that first time, and someone within the club has been blackmailing her ever since. Jack knows he’s hot on the trail when the next death turns out to be that of his mentor at the law firm. Stable manager Tara Flynn clues in Jack to the riding club’s dirt and also provides romantic interest and an investigative assistant he can trust. Meanwhile, Jack’s other case, about medical insurance, gives him the break he needs. VERDICT Winner of the SouthWest Writers (SWW) grand-prize Storyteller Award for 2010, trial lawyer Greaves’s delightful debut, which the SWW also named Best Mystery of 2010, cleverly intermingles equestrian show jumping, insurance claims, and high-tech science in this sunny California thriller. Great readalikes for tone would be Jack Fredrickson and Spencer Quinn. [Greaves’s second book, Hard Twisted, was named best historical novel of 2010 by the SouthWest Writers and will be published by Bloomsbury USA this fall.‚ Ed.]

starred review starHicks, Jonathan. The Dead of Mametz: The First Thomas Oscendale Novel. Y Lolfa, dist. by Dufour. Apr. 2012. c.332p. ISBN 9781847713155. pap. $16.95. M

In the early years of World War I, a chance battlefield encounter between a German soldier who had worked in Wales and a Welsh soldier led to a precious piece of paper‚ a treasure map‚ being passed on to Corporal Vincent. Flash forward to 1916 when, in the Allies’ barracks near Mametz Wood, France, Vincent shoots two of his colleagues and then kills himself. First, however, he passes the piece of paper to another soldier. Enter Det. Thomas Oscendale, a military policeman, who soon has two incidents because a local French widow is murdered, perhaps by a British soldier. Too many coincidences make Oscendale think the cases are connected, but it takes digging to ascertain the motivation behind such personal crimes. Oscendale doesn’t know it, but certain Germans want that map, too, and amid horrific battles, another layer of intrigue ignites. VERDICT This satisfying historical debut partners abundant military and battle details with breathtaking spy adventure on both sides of the front. It’s perfect timing for all the Downton Abbey‚ spurred interest in World War I.

starred review starCasey, Jane. The Reckoning. Minotaur: St. Martin’s. May 2012. c.368p. ISBN 9780312622008. $24.99. M

After her acclaimed debut, The Burning, Casey delivers a second tension-filled thriller featuring DC Maeve Kerrigan, who works for a major crimes team of the Metropolitan London Police. This time Kerrigan is investigating a series of gruesome murders with Detective Inspector Derwent, who is new to the team. Kerrigan finds her colleague somewhat ambivalent about rushing to identify the murderer because the victims all have criminal records as sex offenders involving children. When a break in the case leads to a mobster and his missing teenage daughter, Kerrigan, Derwent, and the entire major crimes team move fast but still risk running out of time. VERDICT Casey has succeeded in writing another impossible-to-put-down thriller with surprising plot twists and well-developed, intriguing characters. Readers will want to know what happens to Kerrigan next!‚ Lisa Hanson O’Hara, Univ. of Manitoba Libs., Winnipeg

starred review starFreed, David. Flat Spin: A Cordell Logan Mystery. Permanent. May 2012. c.300p. ISBN 9781579622725. $29. M

At 43, Cordell Logan has retired from being a National Security go-to guy (assassin) and Air Force pilot. He just wants to be a flight instructor with his beloved 1973 Cessna, the Ruptured Duck. Then his beautiful ex-wife Savannah asks him to help find the killer of her husband, Logan’s former boss, friend, and fellow agent. Russian oil deals, several more murders, and a mysterious ex-father-in-law tycoon complicate matters as Logan battles to clear his own name, avoid pursuers, and figure out his feelings for Savannah, who left him for his ex-boss. VERDICT A pilot, screenwriter, and Pulitzer Prize‚ winning journalist with a military background, Freed manages to introduce into his debut mystery lots of technology without tedious detail. Logan is a wisecracking on-the-wagon protagonist who finds his violent past still has its uses. This series launch is a delightful romp through the familiar hard-boiled scene with a literate hero who admits he is so far failing to find tranquility with the Buddha. Highly recommended.‚ Roland C. Person, formerly with Southern Illinois Univ. Lib., Carbondale

The following titles are reviewed in the April 1 print issue. Visit our Reviews Center (Beta) for the full reviews.


Helms, Richard. The Unresolved Seventh. Five Star: Gale Cengage. Apr. 2012. c.300p. ISBN 9781432825874. $25.95. M

McCarthy, Keith. Nor All Your Tears: A Dr. Lance Elliot Mystery. Severn House. Apr. 2012. c.208p. ISBN 9780727881199. $28.95. M


Arthurson, Wayne. A Killing Winter. Forge: Tor. Apr. 2012. c.304p.ISBN 9780765324184. $24.99. M

Grabenstein, Chris. Fun House: A John Ceepak Mystery. Pegasus Crime. May 2012. c.336p. ISBN 9781605983363. $25. M

Jones, Merry. Behind the Walls: A Harper Jennings Mystery. Severn House. Apr. 2012. c.224p. ISBN 9780727881182. $28.95. M

Knode, Helen. Wildcat Play. Houghton Harcourt. Apr. 2012. c.320p. ISBN 9780151004294. $24. M

Linnéa, Sharon. These Violent Delights. Arundel. (Movie Mystery Bk. 1). Apr. 2012. c.388p. ISBN 9781933608617. $24.95; pap. ISBN 9781933608600. $14.95. M

Olshan, Joseph. Cloudland. Minotaur: St. Martin’s. Apr. 2012. c.304p. ISBN 9781250000170. $24.99. M


Ace, Cathy. The Corpse with the Silver Tongue: A Cait Morgan Mystery. Touchwood, dist. by Midpoint Trade. Apr. 2012. c.240p. ISBN 9781927129098. pap. $14.95. M

Belle, Josie. 50% Off Murder: A Good Buy Girls Mystery. Berkley Prime Crime. Apr. 2012. c.282p. ISBN 9780425247020. pap. $7.99. M

Chase, Erika. A Killer Read: An Ashton Corners Book Club Mystery. Berkley Prime Crime. Apr. 2012. c.304p. ISBN 9780425247037. pap. $7.99. M


Hart, Carolyn. Death Comes Silently: A Death on Demand Mystery. Berkley Prime Crime. Apr. 2012. c.288p. ISBN 9780425245705. $24.95. M

Holt, Anne. Blind Goddess: A Hanne Wilhelmsen Novel. Scribner. Jun. 2012. c.352p. tr. from Norwegian by Tom Geddes. ISBN 9781451634761. pap. $15. M

McGee, James. Hawkwood: A Regency Crime Thriller. Pegasus Crime. May 2012. c.416p. ISBN 9781605983684. $25.95. M

Russell, Sheldon. Dead Man’s Tunnel. Minotaur: St. Martin’s. Jun. 2012. c.304p. ISBN 9781250001009. $25.99. M

Speller, Elizabeth. The Strange Fate of Kitty Easton. Houghton Harcourt. Jul. 2012. c.416p. ISBN 9780547547527. $25. M