Dear BEA: I Hate You; Now Change

Sitting in the emergency room of Roosevelt Hospital last Tuesday, I remember thinking, Librarians are crazy.

I’d just come from the annual AAP-sponsored dinner in their honor, where I’d sat across from two affable pros from DC Public all aglow from the presentations of Cory Doctorow et al. There’s nothing better than BookExpo America for collection management, one declared as an AAP associate handed out swag bags stuffed with the speakers’ titles. Like many other librarians I’d met at the show, she had paid her own way and used vacation days to swing the midweek schedule. It’s worth it, she attested.

I’m glad she got a return on her hard-earned time and cash. Speaking as a ten-year veteran of BEA, I can’t echo the sentiment. I’m just going to come out and say it: I’ve hated the whole enterprise since 2000, when I first attended as an assistant for Library Journal. My naive assumption then was that a small city grew up in an airless, sunless space with inedible food to gather the people who make publishers, agents, editors, writers, press, and librarians jobs possible‚ readers. How confused I was not to witness publicists engaging throngs of the book-buying public or attend an editor-led panel eliciting the opinions of that same demographic. What I saw instead were mysterious transactions taking place over tables stocked with covetable sandwiches and bottled fizzy water, gratis galleys stacked waist-high in little towers guarded with the ferocity of Genghis Khan, Elvis impersonators pointing at their hunks of burning love, and, of course, the odd D-list celebrity (remember Heidi Fleiss and Tom Sizemore?).

The older I got, the less patience I had for the ridiculousness. After the success of the iPod (which signaled the beginning of the ebook era to me) and the first deaths of major newspaper review forums, I didn’t understand how they got away with being so irrelevant. I used to stand in LJ‘s Librarians’ Lounge conjuring Travis Bickle from Taxi Driver: Someday, a real rain will come and wash all this P.T. Barnumism from the aisles‚Ķ

For better and for worse, you don’t get accosted by The King or spy many book orders being placed anymore. But it would be a mistake to conclude that BEA has adapted to the sea changes in book culture. True: this year’s iteration featured a Digital Book Zone to address the surge in e-media and a DIY Authors Conference to embrace the print-on-demand explosion. But no matter where I was standing in the Javits, I sensed a prickly resistance to reckon with what has always been true: that publishing has never been about Us, the supposed tastemakers, gatekeepers, purse-string holders, critics, and consultants. We’ve never held the power‚ we just got too good at making self-delusion our business.

BEA 2010’s packed-to-the-walls panel on The Next Decade in Book Culture (video here) lent credence to my inkling. This forum sponsored by the National Book Critics Circle, an organization I respect deeply, should’ve minted a fresh publishing manifesto that pointed back to readers‚ who they are, what they want, how they fragment and cluster‚ but it devolved instead into How To Get Published 101, with some of the panelists holding forth on how not to bother them (very 1999, comrades). Add to that the missed opportunities for publishers, librarians, and vendors to discuss a sustainable e-book model and the nasty case of hives that sent me to Roosevelt Hospital, and you’ve got a below-average conference experience. (I was allergic to my dress, not BEA, as it turns out.)

Still, there is a light. After every BEA, I drag my jaded ass home in awe of the intimacy collection development and reader’s advisory librarians foster with their patrons. The way they work the show is a thing of beauty, hustling for just-the-right books for just-the-right readers, gleaning and sparking word of mouth‚ the magic of publishing‚ like some kind of Tolkien faeries. Wherever you are, you move me with your passion, good will, good humor, and maddening insistence to keep caring about a trade show that has overlooked your genius for decades.

(For more coverage of BEA 2010, see the June 3 edition of BookSmack!)

Heather McCormack About Heather McCormack

Heather McCormack (, HuisceBeatha on Twitter) is Editor, Book Review for Library Journal.


  1. Kay says:

    Thank you for saying what so many of us think year after year.

  2. JoJo says:

    Don’t hold back, Heather.

  3. Hi Heather;

    Allergic to your DRESS? That could make a great book title. Good for you for soldiering on and attending the show. Sounds like you’re sorry you did.

    As the organizer of the panel that was “the missed opportunities for publishers, librarians, and vendors to discuss a sustainable e-book model,” I can’t help but agree with you and accept the blame for it being a disappointment to you. On the other hand, public forums are not the best venue for discussions of business models. I wish we could have included a trade publisher willing to discuss fears about making ebooks available through libraries, but many are understandably unwilling to do so to an audience of librarians. Fortunately, Macmillan CEO John Sargent engaged with several librarians in a private discussion on the topic at BEA.

    I thank the panelists for alerting librarians to the issues and giving them some ideas on how they can be part of the solution — by educating their public about the availability of downloadable material and by creating cogent arguments as to why libraries should be able to lend ebooks and audio — that may be the best we can hope for.

    Nora Rawlinson,

    • Heather McCormack says:


      I understand where you’re coming from re: publishers not wanting to talk about business models in public forums. Perhaps more private meetings between CEOs and librarians? In any case, your panel was probably my favorite. I only wish more publishers had been in the audience to see it.

  4. Yes, Heather! I can’t claim your experience nor your knowledge base, but speaking strictly as a librarian, 2010 was my first – and last – BEA. There is absolutely nothing for librarians there. At all. IMHO, librarians could better serve themselves by taking that vacation day and spending it with a variety of recent-mint books from a variety of genres and a cup of tea.

    Approaching any and all publisher booths and kiosks was akin to running headlong into a brick wall. Despite most of them staffed by enough employees to positively crowd the area and block access to review copies. there were zero galleys. Zero.

    All I received from these publishers was a new level of contempt and unhelpfulness. It’s everything I can do to not name actual names right now.

    Truth be told, I didn’t know what to expect at BEA, but I don’t know why publishers would set up such a huge event only to ignore attendees, ‘sponsor’ hour-long lines for signings by unknown authors, and hold some serious-looking ‘meetings’ in their booth areas. Surely there are better venues for these otherwise delightful activities? I don’t plan to waste my time there again.

    But perhaps I’ve been too obtuse or oblique in my criticism? If I had to take a vacation day to do this I would have been punching those unhelpful jerks and toppling every display I passed. And throwing rotten fruit at speakers.

    I did meet many wonderful librarians and saw some old friends, but I could have done that anywhere.

    The opinions expressed here are my own. They don’t reflect anyone else’s. They might be stupid, misinformed, or ignorant, but they’re mine mine mine.

  5. Jack W Perry says:

    Enjoyed this post. BEA does seem to be lost in the past and confused about the future. More secret meetings off the floor and less excitement on the floor. It gets to the point if it is really worth attending at all.

  6. I think the InStlyler is :]

  7. Just what I have been thinking. Your content was amazing.

  8. Ricki Kater says:

    Raise your Claw! These Rangers have it going! Elvis Andrus looked really good in that last game! For all you hardcore Texas Rangers fans join us with your Claws up on FacebookFacebook ht tp://www. facebook. com/clawandantlers

  9. An Australian politican’s call to ban the burqa “for safety” following an armed robbery by a bandit wearing the Islamic veil has triggered heated public debate following similar moves in Europe.

  10. Alycia says:

    Top-notch story it is without doubt. We have been searching for this info.

  11. aircard 3g says:

    Nice read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch because I found it for him (:
    Thank you for lunch!

  12. Wonderful blog by the way!