They’re Gamers, Not “Girl Gamers” | Games, Gamers, & Gaming

The news that Ubisoft will not include a female playable character in the online co-op mode for its upcoming Assassin’s Creed: Unity has reignited the discussion about girls and women who play video games and exactly where they fit into the gaming world.

Boys’ club?

Conventional wisdom holds that video games are traditionally a male pursuit. Most games are designed and developed by men. They tell stories of male heroes fighting against male villains (or femme fatales) to save the world and/or a helpless female. Often, they depict male athletes competing in games of skill and strength; just as often, the player is in the boots of a male soldier as he fights a sanitized, Hollywood version of warfare. It would make perfect sense, given these facts and assumptions, that men would populate the gaming world at a staggering majority.

Yet since the advent of online gaming and the wider acceptance of the pursuit as a legitimate hobby for adults, everyone who has bothered to do so has noticed that girls and women play games almost as much (and enjoy as much variety) as boys and men. There’s nothing unusual about “gamer girls”; they’re simply part of the same club to which all gamers belong.

Most players are largely accepting of “gamer girls,” too. Women work at game stores, they participate in organized competitions, and they play online right alongside their male brethren.

Cherchez la femme!

That doesn’t mean that everything’s hunky-dory, of course. Women and girls who play video games are too often treated as an adorable novelty. Additionally, women are not fairly represented as producers of video games, nor are they well depicted within productions.

Two of the strongest female characters in games of rlaracroft080714 Theyre Gamers, Not Girl Gamers | Games, Gamers, & Gamingecent vintage—Catwoman from Batman: Arkham City and Lara Croft from Tomb Raider—are preexisting personae, with no major original female video game character having debuted in quite some time (Heavy Rain from 2010 is the most recent major release I could find with a female lead).

Female characters more often than not fulfill traditional feminine roles: damsel in distress, girlfriend or wife, tactical support, or villainess. Also, they are rarely represented with realistic body types (Lara Croft from the latest Tomb Raider is a notable exception—she’s athletic and strong without having unrealistic proportions). If more women were game designers, developers, testers, and critics, perhaps this would change; however, there must be a shift toward accepting women in development roles.

The women behind the game

Jennifer Hepler was a senior writer for BioWare, developers of the acclaimed “Dragon Age” series. After a lukewarm reception to the second game, a fan unearthed an interview in which Hepler remarked that she wanted to find a way to skip combat sequences so that she could get to what she loved the most—story and character progression—and what seemed like the entire Internet unleashed a torrent of rage upon her. The reactions to Hepler’s comments were out of all proportion to what she said.

Haven’t we all experienced a moment when we just wished we could skip this boss fight and move on? If a female writer can ignite such ire by expressing a desire to follow a game’s story, imagine the hatred a female level designer would ignite should a game be found less than desirable.

The gaming community should promote an environment of acceptance and safety, where criticisms are fair and based on performance, not gender. It’s the only way this diverse, eccentric sphere of ours can survive—and the games themselves can only benefit.

The library can be a flash point for that culture. Gaming programs should be for all ages and all genders as much as possible. Related programs, such as coding camps, should also be gender neutral. Rules of conduct should directly address gender slurs. When conducting advisory for girls who like games, don’t assume that they only enjoy match-three puzzle games and business simulations.

Teaching opportunities

All in all, be as democratic and accepting of your participants—of either gender—as you are of other patrons. Learn about—and tell your patrons about—women such as Kim Swift, whose student project led directly to a job as level designer and development team leader of ­Portal. Buy into programs such as Girls Make Games, a series of camps designed to encourage girls to enter game development. Larger libraries might be able to get the all-female professional gaming team Frag Dolls to come in for a program.girlsmakegames080714 Theyre Gamers, Not Girl Gamers | Games, Gamers, & Gaming

The International eSports Foundation recently rescinded its decision to separate women and men in their game tournaments. While women-only competition still exists, there are no men-only contests, and women can register for the “Open for All” tournaments. This is a small step toward putting female gamers on equal footing with their male counterparts, but it is a step. Let’s encourage the gaming community—creators and consumers alike—to keep making those steps.

Thanks to Liz Danforth for the tip about Girls Make Games. Until next time, keep telling yourself just one more level.

M. Brandon Robbins is Media Coordinator, Goldsboro High School, NC, and a member of the 2011 class of the American Library Association’s Emerging Leaders

This article was published in Library Journal's August 1, 2014 issue. Subscribe today and save up to 35% off the regular subscription rate.

Share
M. Brandon Robbins About M. Brandon Robbins

M. Brandon Robbins (mbrandon.robbins@gmail.com) is the Media Coordinator at Goldsboro High School in Goldsboro, NC. He's a member of the 2011 class of ALA Emerging Leaders.

Comments

  1. Julie says:

    Some other examples do come to mind — Remember Me, Bayonetta, The Walking Dead S2, Beyond: Two Souls, Assassin’s Creed III: Liberation, Final Fantasy XIII and sequels, the in-development Dreamfall Chapters — but yep, definitely still underrepresented compared to the abundance of straight white 30-something brown-haired male protagonists. Great post, thanks for writing it.

  2. Brandon says:

    I am so sorry it took me this long to reply to you, Julie; I just am now noticing your comments, and the comment notification got buried in my email. So, apologies, but I do want to respond to what you said.

    You are right about those games, and they are all certainly major releases. I was thinking more about games that had major hype/buzz leading up to them and got extensive journalistic coverage. Bayonetta certainly fits the bill, and it’s my oversight for not including it. I’m sure the other games had just as much hype and attention as well, but with so much gaming coverage out there, even I can’t keep up. Assassin’s Creed: Liberation is another solid pick that I shouldn’t have missed.

    You bring up an interesting related point in mentioning the ” straight white 30-something brown-haired male protagonists.” The misrepresentation doesn’t stop at gender, but extends into race and sexual orientation. True, with games with deep character creation and role-play aspects, I can make a character of any skin color, cultural background, age, and sexual orientation I want, but it would be nice if game developers stepped up and acknowledged that non-straight, non-white people of all genders and ages exist.

Comment Policy:
  1. Be respectful, and do not attack the author or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  3. Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through (though some comments with links to multiple URLs are held for spam-check moderation by the system). If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.

We accept clean XHTML in comments, but don't overdo it and please limit the number of links submitted in your comment. For more info, see the full Terms of Use.

Speak Your Mind

*

Featuring YD Feedwordpress Content Filter Plugin